The tale of a Greek playwright killed by a tortoise that an eagle dropped from the sky first appears in a Roman book, nearly five centuries after his death. Several famous strange deaths grew the same way, with the detail everyone remembers written down long after the funeral. Others happened exactly as told, and the newspapers had them within a day.

Cool Stories About History is a newsletter to learn history the fun way.
Join free and get:
6 new stories a month, straight to your inbox
The full archive of stories
Comment, ask questions, and chat with other readers
How These Were Chosen
A strange death, here, is one remembered for the unusual way it came, such as a fall down a library staircase or a pistol thought to be empty. All twelve people existed, and they died between the fifth century BC, in Sicily, and 1871, in Ohio.
Several of the details everyone remembers were written down long after the death, and a few are probably legends. They are kept, along with how late they first appeared in writing.
12. Clement Vallandigham (1871)

In June 1871, a murder trial in Lebanon, Ohio, turned on one question. Had a man named Myers been shot by the accused, or by his own pistol? The lawyer arguing for the pistol was Clement Vallandigham, a fifty-year-old who had been one of the most hated men in the North only a few years before.
That hatred dated from the Civil War. Vallandigham sat in Congress for Ohio from 1857 to 1863 and led the Copperheads, the Northern Democrats who wanted the war against the South stopped.
In 1863 he was arrested, tried by a military commission and banished to the Confederacy. He slipped back into Ohio illegally in 1864, and once the war was over he went back to practicing law.
His client, Thomas McGehan, was accused of killing Myers in a barroom brawl. The defense claimed that Myers had pulled his own pistol from his pocket and that it had gone off against him. To win, Vallandigham had to show the jury how that could happen.
On the evening of June 16, after court had risen, he rehearsed the scene for fellow lawyers in his room at the Lebanon hotel. He picked up a pistol he believed was unloaded and pressed it against his side. It fired, and the bullet lodged in his abdomen.
He stayed cheerful through the night and seemed determined not to die. He died at a quarter to ten the next morning, June 17, 1871, and the newspapers had the story within a day. The man he had been defending, Thomas McGehan, was acquitted.
At a Glance
Who: Clement Laird Vallandigham, lawyer and leader of the Copperheads (1820 to 1871)
Date: Shot June 16, died June 17, 1871
Place: His hotel room in Lebanon, Ohio
Cause: An accidental gunshot while demonstrating his client's defense
Oldest account: The newspapers, within a day of the shooting
About This Death
How did Clement Vallandigham die?
While defending a man accused of murder in Lebanon, Ohio, he set out to show that the victim could have shot himself by accident. He used a pistol he believed was unloaded. It fired into his abdomen, and he died the next morning, June 17, 1871.
Who was Clement Vallandigham?
An Ohio congressman and the leader of the Copperheads, the Northern Democrats who opposed the Civil War. Arrested in 1863, he was tried by a military commission and banished to the Confederacy, and he returned in 1864.
11. Valentinian I (375)

In November 375, the Roman emperor Valentinian I received peace envoys in his army camp at Brigetio, on the Danube. They came from the Quadi, a Germanic people whose raiders had been burning the Roman province south of the river. He began to answer, flew into a rage and lost his voice in mid-sentence, and soon his men were rounding up witnesses so that nobody could call it murder.
