12 Famous Popes in History, Saints and Scoundrels

In 1045 a pope sold his office to his own godfather for a pension. In 1983 another pope sat in a prison cell with the man who had shot him. Between those two scenes, the popes who led the Catholic Church stood up to kings and emperors, and a few of their decisions still shape daily life far from Rome. Here are twelve of them, each remembered for one moment.

Perugino's fresco of Christ handing the keys to Saint Peter in a wide piazza
Pietro Perugino, The Delivery of the Keys, 1481 to 1482. Sistine Chapel, Vatican City. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Cool Stories About History is a newsletter to learn history the fun way.

Join free and get:

  • 6 new stories a month, straight to your inbox

  • The full archive of stories

  • Comment, ask questions, and chat with other readers

Free in your inbox.


How These Were Chosen

The pope is the bishop of Rome and the head of the Catholic Church. Twelve of them are gathered here, from the fifth century to 1983, saints and men of scandal side by side.

Each one was kept for a single dated scene and for what came of it, sometimes far from Europe, in China or the Americas.

The less familiar names open the page, and the pope most Americans still remember closes it.


12. Benedict IX (1032 to 1048)

A round portrait medallion of Pope Benedict IX
Portrait medallion of Pope Benedict IX, 19th century. Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, Rome. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

A council at Sutri, a small town north of Rome, met in December 1046 to decide which of three men was the real pope. A council is a meeting of bishops called to settle the affairs of the Church. One of the three, Benedict IX, had sold the office the year before, and another was the man who had bought it.

Benedict owed his throne to his family, the counts of Tusculum, who had already given Rome two popes. They pushed him into the papacy in 1032 while he was still a youth.

His conduct grew so violent that the Romans rose against him, and he fled the city. In January 1045 they elected a rival, Sylvester III, but Benedict's brothers soon drove the new pope out. Benedict then put the office up for sale.

The buyer was his godfather, a Roman priest named Giovanni Graziano, who offered him a pension to step aside. Graziano became Pope Gregory VI in May 1045. Within a year Benedict and Sylvester were both back, each claiming the papacy against him.

At Sutri the matter was settled by Henry III, who ruled the German-led empire later called the Holy Roman Empire. Sylvester was imprisoned, Benedict deposed, and Gregory charged with simony, the buying or selling of Church offices. All three gave way to a new pope, Clement II.

Benedict was not finished. When Clement II died in October 1047, he seized the throne again a month later, for a third time.

In July 1048 the emperor had him driven out, and he was never seen in Rome again. He is said to have spent his last years as a penitent at the monastery of Grottaferrata.

At a Glance

  • Who: Benedict IX, of the counts of Tusculum

  • What he did: Sold the papacy to his godfather, who became Gregory VI

  • When: Pope three times between 1032 and 1048

  • Where: Rome, and the Council of Sutri in December 1046

  • How it ended: Driven out in July 1048 and never seen in Rome again

About This Pope

  • Who are some of the most bizarre popes in history?

    Benedict IX is a strong candidate, since he was pope three times and once sold the office to his godfather. Pope Joan, the woman a medieval legend put on the throne in secret, never existed. Only a few weeks separated Leo IV and Benedict III, the two popes between whom the legend places her.


11. Innocent III and Magna Carta (1215)

Medieval fresco of Pope Innocent III in his papal robes
Pope Innocent III, 13th-century fresco. Sacro Speco monastery, Subiaco. Photo: Carlo Raso, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

In the summer of 1215, King John of England sent messengers to Rome to get rid of Magna Carta, the charter of rights his barons had forced on him. He expected help from his feudal lord, Pope Innocent III. Why would a king of England answer to a pope, and would the pope really strike the charter down?


See the other 11 famous popes in history, for free. Just leave your email and keep reading.


Subscribe for free to continue reading

Enter your email and get every post from Cool Stories About History.